The producers, however, had harbored high hopes for the success of this film. The director of Freaks was veteran Tod Browning , whose previous outing, Dracula (1931), starring Bela Lugosi, had been a huge box-office hit and is also considered to be a classic horror film. Browning had been interested in crafting a more personal work, and he had urged his producers in the mid-1920s to secure the rights to Tod Robbins’s story “Spurs” (1923) for this purpose. Eventually a script was developed by Willis Goldbeck and Leon Gordon that was loosely based on Robbins’s story, and veteran Merritt B. Gerstad was secured for the cinematography. When a 90-minute film was completed in early 1932, routine test screenings were conducted. However, these screenings proved to be so disastrous that about one-third of the original-cut material was removed from the film, and today all we have left of the film is the 64-minute version that was given a limited commercial release .
Although the film proved to be a financial disaster at the time, nevertheless, more recent viewers have generally been much more sympathetic towards the film – and they have regarded the “freaks” in this film as having been presented in a humane way [3,4,5,6,7,8]. Indeed in this story, the “freaks” are the real protagonists with whom the viewers will empathize. In fact I would agree with Andrew Sarris’s comment on this score that
“‘Freaks’ may be one of the most compassionate movies ever made.” 
The story of Freaks plays out over roughly three phases. The first one introduces to the viewer the many and various figures in this tale. The second phase covers events surrounding the memorable wedding banquet that then takes place. And the final phase shows the dramatic consequences that ensue.
1. A Traveling Circus and Its Performers
The scene now shifts to the backstage areas of a traveling circus, where the various performers are shown in random scenes of convivial social interaction. Many of the figures shown are freaks – deformed people whose physical grotesqueness or dwarfishness is supposed to attract curious spectators. Among the dozen or so freaks who have significant roles here are
- Hans (played by Harry Earles), a dwarf
- Frieda (Daisy Earles), a dwarf who loves Hans
- the Siamese Twins (Daisy and Violet Hilton), two young ladies who are conjoined at the hip
- Schlitzie (Schlitzie), a congenial pinhead
- Half-Woman-Half-Man (Josephine Joseph), a hermaphroditic person whose body is male on one side and female on the other side
- Half-Boy (Johnny Eck) – only the upper-half exists
- the Bearded Lady (Olga Roderick)
- the Human Skeleton (Peter Robinson)
And there are also four other performers with normal physiques who figure prominently in this story:
- Cleopatra (played by Olga Baclanova) is a beautiful trapeze artist.
- Hercules (Henry Victor) is the circus strongman.
- Venus (Leila Hyams) is a comely woman who evidently performs with trained seals.
- Phroso (Wallace Ford) is a circus clown.
But there are clear-cut differences among these four “normal” characters concerning how they treat the freaks. Cleopatra and Hercules, like many of the other circus workers, are scornfully dismissive of the freaks. In contrast, Venus and Phroso treat the freaks cordially as ordinary friends and colleagues – they all belong to the same team. This contrasting treatment is a major thematic element of the story.
Another interesting sequence shows the pretty Siamese Twins, Violet and Daisy, each becoming enthralled with and finally engaged to marry different men, who will somehow have to learn to deal with the conjoined situation of their spouses.
2. The Wedding Banquet
Frieda, concerned that Cleopatra’s flirtations with Hans are only intended to make a fool of her own beloved, goes to the woman and urges her to desist from this mockery. But while speaking to Cleopatra, Frieda inadvertently reveals that Hans is due to inherit a vast fortune in the near future. This news gets Cleopatra’s mind working, and she afterwards reveals to her real lover, Hercules, about her murderous plans to marry Hans and get his money.
The wedding is arranged, and there follows the memorably expressionistic wedding feast for Hans and Cleopatra, with all the freaks in celebratory attendance. During the festivities, everyone gets drunk, and while noone is looking, Cleopatra secretly pours poison into Hans’s wine drink.
Meanwhile the party revellers become increasingly exuberant, and they begin chanting a phrase welcoming Cleopatra into their community:
“Google, goggle, one of us, one of us. . .
Google, goggle, one of us, one of us”
Cleopatra tends to the now-seriously-ill Hans, and when he regains consciousness the next day, she apologizes for her behavior the previous night, telling him she was drunk. But she continues to add poison to the medicine that the doctor has prescribed for Hans.
However, Hans and the other freaks, who have been spying on Cleopatra and have witnessed her adding something to Hans’s medicine, are now suspicious. So Hans only pretends to swallow the medicine she gives him, and he conspires with the other freaks about what they need to do.
This sets the stage for the final sequences on a dark and stormy night with the circus wagons on the move. Hans and his freak colleagues catch Cleopatra red-handed giving the poison to Hans and confront her. Meanwhile, Hercules, who knows that Venus is aware of his and Cleopatra’s murderous scheme, goes to Venus’s wagon with the intent to kill her. But Phroso and other freaks rush to Venus’s defense. Can justice be served? Can the defenseless be saved?
Of course, the freaks are very limited in terms of any physical prowess, especially when compared to Hercules. But we are shown that they can work together as a team, and as I mentioned, their inclusive sense of belonging (to be “one of us”) is a major theme of this story and plays an important role here. What transpires at this point is highly dramatic as the fiercely loyal freaks get the upper-hand.
The story now shifts back to “the present”, with the carnival barker still touting his special freak on display. Only on this occasion, the camera shows the barker’s freak to the viewer, revealing it to be a grotesquely deformed Cleopatra. She now looks like a strange, oversized duck and has become “one of them”.
The final scene is something of a coda, and it shows Hans having inherited his fortune and living solemnly alone in a luxurious mansion. He gets a surprise visit from friends Venus, Phroso, and Frieda, and this serves to bring about a reconciliation between Hans and Frieda, which enables the film to end on a more happy note.
Note that for most of the film, our freaks are the relentlessly oppressed ones; but towards the end, the freaks rally together to take revenge on their oppressors. And yet the 64-minute version we have today does not, thankfully, stand as a typical revenge film. That is because, perhaps accidentally due to the negative reactions from pre-screening audiences and threats of censorship, much of the material ultimately excised from the original 90-minute cut was concerned with vivid acts of vengeance taken on Cleopatra and Hercules . What remained was a film whose overall tone was more humane and more sympathetic towards the freaks.
- Edward Brophy and Mat Mchugh, “Freaks”, Variety, (12 July 1932).
- “Freak show”, Wikipedia, (19 September 2020).
- Alfred Eaker, “TOD BROWNING: DIRECTOR RETROSPECTIVE”, Alfred Eaker, (26 January 2016).
- Gary Morris and Mark A. Vieira, “Todd Browning’s Freaks (1932): Production Notes and Analysis”, Bright Lights Film Journal, (1 April 2001).
- Brian Koller, “filmsgraded.com: Freaks (1932) Grade: 79/100″, FilmsGraded”, (18 February 2018).
- Jeffrey M. Anderson, “Freaks (1932)”, Combustible Celluloid, (n.d.).
- Ed Gonzalez, “Review: Tod Browning’s Freaks”, Slant Magazine, (29 October 2003).
- Gary Giddins, “Still a Pulp Tour de Force”, The New York Sun, (31 August 2004).
- “Freaks (1932 film)”, Release, Wikipedia, (2 October 2020).
- Andrew Sarris, The American Cinema: Directors and Directions, 1929-1968, E. P. Dutton & Co. (1968), p. 229.
- “Freaks (1932 film)”, Censorship, “Wikipedia”, (2 October 2020).